← Blog

GrapheneOS vs LineageOS: Security, Devices and Google Apps Compared

November 17, 2026

Tool Comparisons

GrapheneOS vs LineageOS comes down to one trade: GrapheneOS gives you the strongest security you can get on Android, but only on Google Pixel phones. LineageOS runs on hundreds of phones from dozens of brands, but it keeps your bootloader unlocked on most of them and adds far less hardening. If you own a Pixel 8 or newer and care about privacy, GrapheneOS is the better pick. If you want to keep an older Samsung, Xiaomi or OnePlus phone alive with a clean, current Android, LineageOS is the one that will actually install.

Here's the short version:

  • Security: GrapheneOS adds deep hardening (its own memory allocator, network and sensor permission toggles, auto-reboot) and relocks the bootloader. LineageOS is close to stock Android security and usually leaves the bootloader unlocked.
  • Devices: GrapheneOS supports Pixel 6 through Pixel 10a. LineageOS lists roughly 450 maintained devices.
  • Google apps: GrapheneOS runs real Google Play as an ordinary sandboxed app. LineageOS ships without Google apps; you flash a GApps package or use microG.
  • Updates: Both are current on Android 17. GrapheneOS ships releases several times a month. LineageOS builds weekly.
  • Alternatives: CalyxOS is back after a long 2025 hiatus. /e/OS is a de-Googled Android with microG built in.

Quick Comparison

GrapheneOSLineageOS
Main goalPrivacy and security hardeningKeep phones updated and customizable
Supported devicesPixel 6 to Pixel 10a, Pixel Fold, Pixel TabletAbout 450 maintained devices, many brands
Current baseAndroid 17LineageOS 24, based on Android 17
Bootloader after installRelocked, full verified bootUsually stays unlocked
Google appsSandboxed Google Play, optional, per profileNone included; GApps or microG, your choice
Update cadenceSeveral releases a month, automaticWeekly builds per device
InstallWeb installer or command lineDevice-specific guide; new WebUSB flash tools
Banking appsMany work; some refuseMany work; some refuse
Best forPixel owners who want maximum securityNon-Pixel owners and older phones

Security Model: Hardening vs a Clean Android

The biggest difference isn't features. It's what each project is trying to do.

GrapheneOS: built around exploit resistance

GrapheneOS is a non-profit, open-source project that describes itself as a private and secure mobile operating system with Android app compatibility. Its features page is a long list of changes most users never see:

  • hardened_malloc, its own memory allocator with guard regions, canaries and hardware memory tagging, which makes common memory-corruption exploits much harder.
  • Network permission toggle, so you can cut an app off from the internet entirely. The app just sees the network as down.
  • Sensors permission toggle, which feeds blocked apps zeroed sensor data.
  • Storage Scopes and Contact Scopes, which let you hand an app specific files or contacts instead of everything.
  • Auto reboot after 18 hours locked by default, which puts your data back at rest.
  • USB-C port control that blocks new USB connections while the phone is locked.
  • Duress PIN, which wipes the device if entered at the lock screen.
  • Vanadium, a hardened Chromium browser and WebView.

The other half of the model is the bootloader. GrapheneOS's own install guide says locking the bootloader "is important as it enables full verified boot", and the project treats a phone left unlocked as an incomplete install. Verified boot means the phone checks that the system hasn't been tampered with every time it starts. That's the same protection a stock Pixel has, and most custom ROMs give it up.

LineageOS: stock-level security, more control

LineageOS isn't trying to out-harden Google. It's a community project that takes the Android Open Source Project and keeps it running on phones their makers stopped updating, with extra customization on top.

Security-wise, that means you get Android's normal app sandbox and permission system, plus current monthly security patches merged into each supported version. What you usually don't get is a locked bootloader. The LineageOS FAQ says few devices allow relocking and "even less work properly after that", and warns it can leave a phone unusable. An unlocked bootloader means someone with physical access can flash modified software more easily.

LineageOS also doesn't recommend rooting, and it won't fake security checks. If your device doesn't pass Play Integrity, the FAQ says that's because the project doesn't remove the flags that report an unlocked bootloader: "it isn't our place to lie about security features."

Bottom line: if your threat model includes theft, border searches or targeted attacks, GrapheneOS is in a different league. If you mostly want fewer Google services and a phone that still gets patches, LineageOS is enough.

Device Support: Pixels Only vs Hundreds of Phones

This is where most people's decision gets made for them.

GrapheneOS supports Pixels

The GrapheneOS FAQ lists these as officially supported today:

  • Pixel 10, 10 Pro, 10 Pro XL, 10 Pro Fold and 10a
  • Pixel 9, 9 Pro, 9 Pro XL, 9 Pro Fold and 9a
  • Pixel 8, 8 Pro and 8a
  • Pixel Fold and Pixel Tablet
  • Pixel 7, 7 Pro and 7a
  • Pixel 6, 6 Pro and 6a

Pixel 5a and older are end-of-life. The FAQ explains why the list is so short: most non-Pixel phones lack the hardware and firmware security features GrapheneOS needs, so broad device support would work against the project's goals. It says the full set of requirements is met from the Pixel 8 onward.

GrapheneOS says it plans to work with phone makers to produce devices that meet those requirements, ideally shipping with GrapheneOS preinstalled. Until such a device appears on the supported list, a GrapheneOS phone means a Pixel. If you're buying one for it, a Pixel 8 or newer gets you the full feature set and the longest support window.

LineageOS supports almost everything

The LineageOS device list runs to roughly 450 maintained devices. Xiaomi, Motorola, OnePlus, Samsung and Google make up most of it, with Sony, LG, Fairphone, Nubia, Lenovo, NVIDIA Shield TVs and even some handheld game consoles in the mix.

Two things to know before you get excited:

  1. Not every device runs the newest version. Some maintained devices are on LineageOS 24, others on 23.2 or 22.2. Check your device's wiki page.
  2. Builds aren't guaranteed every week. The FAQ says a week can be skipped because of build failures or device-specific problems, and that a skipped build doesn't mean support has ended.

Pixels are on the LineageOS list too, including older models GrapheneOS has dropped. That makes LineageOS the usual answer for a Pixel 5 or older, as long as your exact model still has a maintainer.

Google Play: Sandboxed Play vs GApps and microG

Most people don't want zero Google. They want their banking app, their messaging app and the Play Store, with less tracking. The two projects solve this differently.

GrapheneOS: real Google Play, no special privileges

GrapheneOS will never include Google Play services or microG in the system. Instead, it has a compatibility layer that lets you install the official Google Play apps as ordinary sandboxed apps. They get the same restrictions as any other app you install, with no system privileges. You can install them in one user profile and keep another profile completely Google-free.

The GrapheneOS usage guide is upfront about the limits. "Some functionality is inherently privileged and can't be provided as part of the compatibility layer." Android Auto works but needs extra permissions you grant yourself. And GrapheneOS isn't certified by Google, so some banking apps that check device certification will refuse to run. GrapheneOS won't spoof those checks. It points app developers to hardware attestation, which can verify other properly signed operating systems.

LineageOS: you choose what to add

LineageOS ships with no Google apps at all. Its Google Apps page says licensing means they "cannot come pre-installed with LineageOS and must be installed separately". You have three options:

  • Nothing. Use F-Droid and other app stores and live without Play services.
  • A GApps package such as MindTheGapps, flashed during install. The wiki warns that if you boot LineageOS before installing it, you'll need to factory reset first or expect crashes.
  • microG, an open-source reimplementation of parts of Play services. LineageOS links a microG guide for this.

A GApps package installs Google's services with system-level privileges, the way a stock phone has them. That's more compatible than GrapheneOS's approach, and less private.

What Android developer verification changes

Google is now requiring that apps on certified Android devices come from identity-verified developers, even when sideloaded. The LineageOS post on developer verification says it is rolling out regionally from September 2026 and globally by 2027, and that it "will not affect LineageOS directly", because the project has never shipped Google's services and isn't bound to install the verifier. The post's one caveat: a GApps package could in theory bundle the verifier, in which case you'd switch packages.

Updates and Android Versions

Both projects are current, which wasn't always true.

GrapheneOS finished its port to Android 17 in June 2026. Its built-in updater checks for new releases about every six hours and installs them in the background, using small delta updates where it can. The releases page shows five releases in the first two weeks of November 2026 alone. GrapheneOS also offers optional security preview releases.

LineageOS 24, based on Android 17, arrived in October 2026. According to the LineageOS 24 changelog, security patches through October 2026 are merged into versions 18.1 through 24.0. The project produces weekly builds, and the updater on the phone installs them.

The practical difference: GrapheneOS updates arrive faster and more often, and they also carry Pixel firmware updates. On LineageOS, firmware updates depend on your device and its maintainer.

Installing Each One (High Level)

Neither install is hard if you follow the official guide, and both wipe your phone. Back up first.

GrapheneOS has an official web installer that runs in a desktop browser over USB. The flow is: enable OEM unlocking, unlock the bootloader, flash, then lock the bootloader again. There's also a command-line guide. The FAQ warns that third-party install guides are often outdated or wrong, so stick to the official one.

LineageOS installs are device-specific. Each phone has its own wiki page, and the steps vary by brand: fastboot for most phones, a separate tool for Samsung. LineageOS 24 adds new browser-based WebUSB flash tools for common install methods, so you need less desktop software. The project still says to follow your device's wiki page.

CalyxOS and /e/OS: Where the Alternatives Stand

These two come up in every GrapheneOS vs LineageOS thread, and their status has changed.

CalyxOS went on hiatus in mid-2025. Its August 2025 post described a last update that warned users their install was unmaintained and said reinstalling would be needed once the project returned. CalyxOS announced it was back on July 1, 2026 with release 7.2.2.0, which needs a clean install if you were on the old line. It has since moved to CalyxOS 8 on Android 17 and shipped November 2026 security updates. CalyxOS offers microG as an optional Play services alternative, and its web installer works with Pixel and Motorola phones. If you stopped trusting it during the pause, it's worth a fresh look, but check that your device is still on its list.

/e/OS is a de-Googled Android from the e Foundation. The /e/OS page says Google services "have been replaced by microG", and Murena sells phones with /e/OS preinstalled. It's the easiest route for someone who wants a de-Googled phone out of the box and doesn't want to flash anything.

What About AI on a De-Googled Phone?

This is the question most comparisons skip, and it matters more every year. Google is putting more of its AI into Android itself, and most of that assumes a stock, Google-certified phone.

Gemini. Google's help page says the Gemini app runs on Android phones with 2 GB of RAM or more on Android 9 and up, and you get it from Google Play. On GrapheneOS, that means installing sandboxed Google Play first, ideally in a separate profile. On LineageOS without GApps, there's no Play Store, so the realistic path is Gemini in a browser. Deeper system features are another story. Google's Gemini Intelligence page lists 12 GB of RAM, a qualified chip and "advanced on-device AI processing capabilities" as requirements. Plan as if those features won't be there on a custom OS.

Local models. This is the de-Googled phone's best AI option. Apps like PocketPal AI and ChatterUI run open models such as Gemma, Qwen and Llama entirely on the phone, and they work without Google services. Google AI Edge Gallery is distributed on Google Play, but its GitHub releases also offer an APK for people without Play access. Our guide to running an LLM locally on Android covers which models fit in how much RAM.

The privacy trade-off. A cloud assistant on a de-Googled phone still sends your prompts to the cloud. GrapheneOS helps here in a concrete way: you can deny an AI app the Network permission and prove to yourself it isn't calling home, or keep cloud AI apps in a separate profile from your personal data. On any of these systems, a local model on a Pixel 8 or newer is the most private AI setup you can run on a phone today.

If you want the broader picture first, see how to use AI on your phone. For agents that tap through apps for you, our AI agents for Android guide covers what works today. And if you're wondering where phones are heading, our explainer on the AI operating system covers the bigger shift.

Where Taku Fits

Choosing a phone system is a decision about trust: who sees your data, and what runs with what permissions. Taku doesn't replace GrapheneOS, LineageOS or any project here. If you'd rather run AI tools someone has already built on your Mac than set up your own, that's where Taku comes in.

Taku Apps and Sites, built by the best AI minds. Find one, run it, and keep it in your Mac Dock. Taku is in Beta, and the Mac app is available now.

Key Points

  • GrapheneOS is the security pick. It adds deep hardening and relocks the bootloader, but it only supports Pixel 6 through Pixel 10a, with full features from Pixel 8.
  • LineageOS is the compatibility pick, with roughly 450 maintained devices across dozens of brands and weekly builds.
  • GrapheneOS runs real Google Play as a sandboxed app. LineageOS leaves Google out; you add GApps or microG.
  • Both are on Android 17 as of late 2026. GrapheneOS ships updates more often, and they include Pixel firmware.
  • CalyxOS returned in July 2026 after a hiatus that began in mid-2025. /e/OS ships with microG built in.
  • On any de-Googled phone, local AI models are the most private option. Cloud AI and Google's system-level AI features depend on Google's apps and certified hardware.

FAQ

Is GrapheneOS more secure than LineageOS?

Yes. GrapheneOS adds exploit mitigations like hardened_malloc, extra permission toggles and auto-reboot, and it relocks the bootloader for full verified boot. LineageOS offers roughly stock Android security and usually stays unlocked.

Can I install GrapheneOS on a Samsung or OnePlus phone?

No. GrapheneOS supports Google Pixel phones only, from Pixel 6 to Pixel 10a plus the Pixel Fold and Pixel Tablet. The project says most other phones lack the hardware security features it requires.

Does Google Play work on GrapheneOS and LineageOS?

On GrapheneOS, you can install the official Google Play apps as sandboxed apps with no special privileges. On LineageOS, Google Play isn't included; you flash a GApps package during install or use microG instead.

Do banking apps work on GrapheneOS or LineageOS?

Many do, and some don't. Apps that require a Google-certified device may refuse to run on either. Neither project spoofs security checks to get around this.

Is CalyxOS still maintained?

Yes. CalyxOS paused in mid-2025 and announced its return on July 1, 2026 with version 7.2.2.0. It has since released CalyxOS 8 on Android 17, with November 2026 security updates.

Can I use AI on GrapheneOS or LineageOS?

Yes. Local model apps like PocketPal AI and ChatterUI run fully offline without Google services. The Gemini app needs Google Play, which you can add as sandboxed Play on GrapheneOS. On LineageOS without GApps, use Gemini in a browser.